Log In
July 19, 2013
Offline
I have a non-collector friend has put a deposit on this gun. I could help him avoid a big mistake if anyone can comment on any non-original options. Seller says Pauline Muerel confirms Ulrich engraving. Long time high end seller.
Any quick help appreciated or price comments. PM me if that is a better way.
Bill
November 7, 2015
Offline
Just a question from the peanut gallery here: why does an offering in this class not have a letter?
July 19, 2013
Offline
Some winchester records were lost in fire, or used in furnace, so might be true. Just trying to see. I thought the 1873 22’s were made later than 1886, as this serial number indicates,
November 7, 2015
Offline
I’d certainly make a call to find out. Date on the monogram is the year following build date. Seems like seller is trying to imply factory engraving when that may not be the case. Not sure how much that matters but I’d guess it was returned for engraving and other modifications but a letter would be a first step in figuring that out.
May 2, 2009
Offline
I wouldn’t even consider buying it unless I had checked how it lettered and saw the letter that Pauline would of wrote with her opinion. I would want to see if she said it was Ulrich that did the work. Even then the gun has a lot of condition issues.
Bob
WACA Life Member--- NRA Life Member---- Cody Firearms member since 1991 Researching the Winchester 1873's
Email: [email protected]
November 7, 2015
Offline
Red Book/PRB date appears to be late 1885. I wonder how they determined the work was done by John Ulrich. From what I’ve read all the engravers could copy the others’ styles, much like some of the “old masters’ ” paintings were actually done by students in the masters’ styles. Seems a screw or two have been replaced. Looks like the spring for the elevator is a bit tired or something else is amiss internally. Not sure how 22 short qualifies as “rare” but I guess all things are relative.
June 4, 2017
Offline
The finish of the various parts, stock, barrel, tube, and receiver, does not look original. First step is letter the gun, but even if it letters, a gun like that is easy to buy but will be a hard to sell. T/R
November 7, 2015
Offline
TR said
The finish of the various parts, stock, barrel, tube, and receiver, does not look original. First step is letter the gun, but even if it letters, a gun like that is easy to buy but will be a hard to sell. T/R
That bothered me as well, some parts of the receiver show considerable wear while the barrel and mag tube look nearly new. Other parts appear to be somewhere in between.
May 2, 2009
Offline
It has the wrong stock on it as well. The butt plate use to be a swiss butt but they cut the ends off.
Bob
WACA Life Member--- NRA Life Member---- Cody Firearms member since 1991 Researching the Winchester 1873's
Email: [email protected]
November 19, 2006
Offline
My impression is that it is not real. I’m willing to be wrong, but I’d have to be proven wrong. I would not be willing to go with someone else’s impression to change my mind.
Also, your friend is a, “non-collector”? I’m just trying to figure out what a non-collector would be doing buying this rifle? Surely not for speculation purposes?
April 15, 2005
Offline
Bill,
As others have stated… get the Cody letter. While I trust Pauline’s assessment of who engraved it, that rifle should already have a Factory letter with it.
In my opinion, the asking price is too high for the condition of the rifle.
Bert
WACA Historian & Board of Director Member #6571L
July 19, 2013
Offline
Thanks folks, I’ll try to talk him out of it.
the guys rich and the gun is pretty.
also getting a hard sales pitch
Bill
November 17, 2011
Offline
Hard to believe the cartoonish style of the animals is Ulrich? Nothing like my Ulrich engraved Model 12 Trap that was engraved by his son.
December 1, 2012
Offline
For $ 25K I would expect the seller to have better pictures – at least some taken by a $220 camera. For that price there should be a Cody letter. Also the wood definitely seems to have been refinished and sanded down, at the upper tang and at top of the front edge of the forearm. The carrier also doesn’t look right.
"This is the West, sir. When the legend becomes fact, print the legend."
June 4, 2017
Offline
Wincacher said
For $ 25K I would expect the seller to have better pictures – at least some taken by a $220 camera. For that price there should be a Cody letter. Also the wood definitely seems to have been refinished and sanded down, asd the upper tang and at top of the front edge of the forearm. The carrier also doesn’t look right.
Great point, you hit the nail on the head. Pictures of the butt plate, barrel address, barrel caliber stamp, and upper tang markings would answer a lot of questions. T/R
July 19, 2013
Offline
Bert H. said
Bill,
As others have stated… get the Cody letter. While I trust Pauline’s assessment of who engraved it, that rifle should already have a Factory letter with it.
In my opinion, the asking price is too high for the condition of the rifle.
Bert
Bert H. said
Bill,
As others have stated… get the Cody letter. While I trust Pauline’s assessment of who engraved it, that rifle should already have a Factory letter with it.
In my opinion, the asking price is too high for the condition of the rifle.
Bert
One of the most elaborately engraved Winchesters you will ever see” ~ Pauline Muerrel
I notice the seller quotes Pauline saying the above….not verifying it as Ulrich.
you guys are great…..i’m Thankful for you all to help me help a friend. At best, this gun is a “ work of art” not the real thing. Bill
January 24, 2013
Offline
First, I would contact Pauline and ensure that she made that comment.
Looks like platinum band at breech and gold bands at muzzle is different.
Just my thoughts
November 7, 2015
Offline
I’ve learned to look at what is apparent and look for what ISN’T there as well. I’m a newbie collector but I’ve used this approach in my other endeavors. I suspect the seller has a Cody letter in hand in addition to the referenced letter from Ms. Muerrle but neither support the seller’s description. Most sellers of a gun in this price range would post a picture of these letters if they had them, and apparently they do. Something’s missing and I’m thinking it’s not something the seller wants a buyer to know, IMHO.
June 4, 2017
Offline
Why is there a big screw head in the front tang screw hole and why would Winchester allow a in house engraver to engrave the upper tang over the model number? T/R
December 1, 2012
Offline
All good observations, gentlemen. We’d best stop critiquing this poor specimen lest we discover it was really made in Italy by Uberti. 
"This is the West, sir. When the legend becomes fact, print the legend."
