
I have an 1889 38.40 model and wanted to mount it in inoperable condition so children couldn’t operate it. So I removed those two “toggles” inside the side plates. I didn’t want a trigger lock showing for display purposes. Could someone still insert a cartridge into the breech ( if they had one, I don’t keep any ammo for it ), manually pull the hammer back and fire it? If so, what’s the easiest way to prevent that ( minimum disassembly)
I’ll have to figure out how to get a video or photo in here.
Randall, I have seen 73’s with small wooden plugs tapped in the breech and muzzle end of the barrel. The one in the breech is shaped like the cartridge without the rim so it won’t catch the ejector, the one in the muzzle is a dowel tapped in the rifling. To remove you turn a wood screw in the plug in the muzzle and pull it then use a cleaning rod to tap out the one in the breech. Check State law wording to see if it requires a lock. Unless you remove the firing pin the gun can fire, without the toggles the bolt is coming “BACK” when fired. T/R
TR said
Randall, I have seen 73’s with small wooden plugs tapped in the breech and muzzle end of the barrel. The one in the breech is shaped like the cartridge without the rim so it won’t catch the ejector, the one in the muzzle is a dowel tapped in the rifling. To remove you turn a wood screw in the plug in the muzzle and pull it then use a cleaning rod to tap out the one in the breech. Check State law wording to see if it requires a lock. Unless you remove the firing pin the gun can fire, without the toggles the bolt is coming “BACK” when fired. T/R
Thanks TR. Yes I now realize I’ve actually made it more dangerous. The rifle needs to be 100% child proof so I’ll probably look for a wall mount rack that has a locking feature. Even if I find a trigger lock about the same color as the rifle, I’d rather leave as much of it exposed to view as possible. Possibly a cable lock. If I thought I could remove the firing pin without buggering things up I’d do that ( not a gunsmith )
Randall,
I would second to remove the firing pin and then put it in the butt stock if you don’t have rods in there already so you don’t lose it.
Bob
WACA Life Member--- NRA Life Member---- Cody Firearms member since 1991 Researching the Winchester 1873's
Email: [email protected]
If you have already removed the toggles you are at the point where the firing pin could be removed. The only thing holding it in is the forward pin that the toggle goes to, the one that goes through the bolt. On the left side there is a little lever that retracts the firing pin and is held in by that pin. If the pin can be removed easily the little lever drops down and then the firing pin can be removed out the back with the hammer pulled back all the way. Sometimes the hammer does not go far enough back to make it side out. I just tried one of my guns and it came out.
Bob
WACA Life Member--- NRA Life Member---- Cody Firearms member since 1991 Researching the Winchester 1873's
Email: [email protected]
[email protected] said
Yes 1873 Winchester as in the topic. The serial number places it in 1889 as far as manufacture date.
Sorry, the post was a little confusing for me. Post the entire serial number and someone may give you a more concise date.
November 7, 2015

Is this the only firearm these children will ever encounter? Teaching a child about guns makes more sense than trying to child-proof a gun. But yes, removing the firing pin is the most practical way to render most firearms inert.
Mike
Hi Randall. Best thing to do to your 1873 Rifle, to make it safe is do what Bob said, remove firing pin and store safely.Now get another old firing pin,[plenty of these around] and grind the front pin section off. Reassemble. Only you will know it wont fire, and you will have a complete non firing but working Rifle.
Eric
I agree with Eric. Also I’d put the toggle links back in, so you could see how the rifle functions / cycles, and you could dry fire it as well.
Maverick
WACA #8783 - Checkout my Reloading Tool Survey!
https://winchestercollector.org/forum/winchester-research-surveys/winchester-reloading-tool-survey/
1 Guest(s)
