Log In
Members
Home
Add Reply
Add Topic
Perusing the Internet, I found a Winchester Garand priced at $3,500. Is this normal? The rifle was not 100% correct either. Here’s a 100% original WIN-13, in 95% + condition with mint bore and strong cartouche and circle “P”. Are they asking or getting prices like this for Winchester Garands? This rifle was a gift, so I have no idea what it would bring. Big Larry
They will if they are 100% original.
Especially the Win 13 being original. Win13 will always be more collectible bc of the books. lol
But to get those prices it will have to be original and not a restoration, orignal finishes, unsanded cartouched stock
I sold a mint original WRA in the 2.35 range not long ago. All original and looked like it came from the factory yesterday.
I got 3k for it.
They honestly have came down in price since about 2007ish, when they hit their highest.
I sold two WIN13’s that were original and mint, for like $7500 or $8500. I doubt they would sell for even half that today.
Thanks Steve. I guess I sold my US Military collection at a good time. I too got top dollar for my stuff. Big Larry
steven norton said
They honestly have came down in price since about 2007ish, when they hit their highest.
Remember that the next time you hear a dealer say “buy now, it will only go up!”
Antiques Roadshow frequently runs programs from about 8-10 yrs ago, showing estimated values then & now; “now” is lower most of the time, sometimes drastically. I never bought anything expecting to “make money” on it, but neither did I ever imagine I was setting myself up for major losses.
I have been looking for an all original Garand for at least 5 years. I missed one that sold for $6,000. I had placed a sealed bid at $5000. Recently I found one that is all original Winchester parts but the problem was the stock was stamped with a post war re builders marks. Guy wanted about $3600 for it. He posted pictures of every part with the part number. Some parts were nicer than the rest of the gun. I believe that in today’s market the price was OK. But I coulldn’t live with the stock or the desire to scrape off the marks.
April 26, 2015
Offline
As I recall, 3500 was about the price for a good condition, original/correct Win 13 about 4 or 5 years ago. Scott Duff usually had a nice Winchester on consignment back then and his prices were reasonable. But having spent myself into the poorhouse, I said “next time” but he stopped selling rifles and now I’ll probably never have a Winchester M1. Interest is waning and I realize there’s no reason for it other than the hunt to find one.
Now I’m headed to that poorhouse again because of lever action Winchesters! BK
Bruce Koligian said
As I recall, 3500 was about the price for a good condition, original/correct Win 13 about 4 or 5 years ago. Scott Duff usually had a nice Winchester on consignment back then and his prices were reasonable. But having spent myself into the poorhouse, I said “next time” but he stopped selling rifles and now I’ll probably never have a Winchester M1. Interest is waning and I realize there’s no reason for it other than the hunt to find one.Now I’m headed to that poorhouse again because of lever action Winchesters! BK
I feel your pain Bruce. I divested myself of almost all my US military weapons except a couple Carbines, a papered USMC M1903, a Rem. 03-A3, a really nice M97 Trenchgun, a minty Colt M1911A1, and a Thompson SMG. I took to collecting Winchester lever guns, then went to Smith and Wessons, and finally Winchester rimfires. On a retirement and SS, so I don’t have a lot of $$$ to spend any longer, but I keep a foot in the door. The Garand was a gift from a friend, and as far as I can tell, it is 100% correct. Big Larry
1 Guest(s)
