Log In
Members
Home
Add Reply
Add Topic
https://www.gunbroker.com/item/969632495
They do look a bit unusual.
Description:
20 rd 44-40 WIN 200 gr Hornady XTP Modified/trimmed 44 Mag Brass 1300 fps 24″ bar RELOAD Mainly for hunting or Defense Rifle
FOR 1860 Henry’s or Winchester 1873 Etc. These have trouble chambering in Model 1892 and 1894
See Pictures for Trim work
Licensed ATF FFL 5-74-091-06-5D-12501 Class 06-Manufacturer of Ammunition for Firearms
And:
1. SAFETY Safety is the main concern. We load every round as though we were going to shoot it ourselves. Attention to every detail is of prime importance. Starting with the case, check correct caliber, length, size, Primer Pocket, If it is once or more fired, then an inspection to see if cracks, deformities, dents, scratches, would deem it unsafe to use. New cases still need to be inspected as well–generally they are fine. The correct primer is used according to the loading manual, they are inspected as well. The correct gunpowder is used, and weighed also as the ammount is necessary for safety, accuracy, consistentcy. Finally before reloading, the bullet itself is inspected for weight, dents, coating, tip,
2. RESIZING We use a Press and the appropriate Die for each caliber/Cartridge to RESIZE the Case. For Bolt, Lever, Break-open action firearms, the neck is all that needs resizing, the body of the case you can leave alone because it will fit back in the chamber in order to have a consistent fit every shot. We dont load much ammo for these type of actions.
steve004 said
FOR 1860 Henry’s or Winchester 1873 Etc. These have trouble chambering in Model 1892 and 1894
Illustrates wonderfully why proof of normal (at least) intelligence should be a prerequisite for obtaining an FFL–esp. a Class 6! (Even though it would disqualify half of them.) I suspect the fool is actually referring to Henry & ’73 repros, though it would not seem unreasonable to say so explicitly. ’94s? Yes, I expect the user would find some difficulty with that model.
November 7, 2015
Offline
Not a chance. A commercial reloader that feels full length resizing isn’t necessary should not be loading for the public. Neck sizing will allow it to chamber in the same firearm in which it was last fired and is sometimes a good practice for an individual reloader loading for a specific firearm. A commercial reloader should return the brass to original specs to ensure reliable chambering in all firearms. Also, a 3-5 shot group does not constitute accuracy testing. Three shot groups lie, five is a good start.
I guess I’m a little spoiled; nowadays I only load when I have plenty of time and I have very good equipment and components. I also have over 40 years experience and load well over a dozen different different cartridges.
There’s more to quality reloaded ammo than a brilliant shine.
JMHO, of course.
Mik
I will concede I’ve had a chance to purchase a couple Model 94 .44-40’s over the years (I’m talking post-63 carbines that were probably made in the 70’s). I’m not referring to commemoratives, I’m talking standard .44-40 M94 carbines – similar to the M94 carbine I had in .44 magnum that was made in the early 70’s. I believe these standard .44-40 carbines were originally only available in Canada?
I don’t think these .44-40 carbines were what this ammo manufacturer was referring to. Aside from his M94 comment, I find it interesting that he acknowledges his rounds have trouble chambering in a M1892. I would think a .44-40 chamber is a .44-40 chamber?
November 7, 2015
Offline
steve004 said
(Snip)I don’t think these .44-40 carbines were what this ammo manufacturer was referring to. Aside from his M94 comment, I find it interesting that he acknowledges his rounds have trouble chambering in a M1892. I would think a .44-40 chamber is a .44-40 chamber?
It may be that there was some variation in chamber dimensions before SAAMI but if the cases were full length resized it shouldn’t be an issue. I suspect his reasons for not FL resizing have more to do with precious cases lost to the process.
Mike
The main area to consider is the base portion of then cartridge’s dimensions.
- Case – 44 Mag, .4560″ at the base of full length resize and .4570″ at the very bottom
- Chamber – .4589″ and .4590″ at the same locations
- Case – 44-40, .4689″ at the base of the full length resize and .4711″ at the very bottom
- Chamber – .4697″ and .4718″ at the same locations
Thus the difference between the 44-40 chamber and the 44 Magnum case at the base is enough to cause weakening of the case base area with high pressure loads as the 44 Magnum case base will over expand at the thin area just before the case base gets thick.
Bryan Austin said
The main area to consider is the base portion of then cartridge’s dimensions.
- Case – 44 Mag, .4560″ at the base of full length resize and .4570″ at the very bottom
- Chamber – .4589″ and .4590″ at the same locations
- Case – 44-40, .4689″ at the base of the full length resize and .4711″ at the very bottom
- Chamber – .4697″ and .4718″ at the same locations
Thus the difference between the 44-40 chamber and the 44 Magnum case at the base is enough to cause weakening of the case base area with high pressure loads as the 44 Magnum case base will over expand at the thin area just before the case base gets thick.
Hence, assuming the barrel is not setback, it is not possible to rechamber a .44-40 to .44 magnum and end up with exact .44 magnum chamber dimensions/
1 Guest(s)
