July 31, 2005
OfflineReading through my Fall 2026 edition on page 55 I found the August 21, 1903 letter from Winchester management to “Missionaries & Salesmen” quite interesting. They are essentially explaining the company reasons for parting ways with the Browning brothers.
The first line from the final paragraph sums up the company position. “We shall be perfectly able to get along without the Brownings, and shall probably be better off without them than with them.” Queue Grumpy Cat
What do you think? Maybe it would have been better to make an agreement that benefitted all.

I call myself a collector as it sounds better than hoarder
December 9, 2002
OfflineBill,
I also have found that quite interesting and was meaning to comment on it, but well you know, those thoughts are somewhere up there, in one of them clouds we keep hearing about all the information and such going to. LOL!
From reading this, and several of the Browning books out there and their side of the story, I’m not sure that I am in agreement with you. My point is the fact that there’s always that old proverbial statement of being more than one side of the story. We also understand how long ago this was and that people thought, acted, and operated differently in those archaic times.
A couple heavy hitters with Winchester being the Big Dog on the block so to speak, JMB, will, and has gone down in History as being one of, if not the Best gun inventor of all times.
I’ve been at the bargaining table, as many other collectors here have as maybe you have also, as we all like to barter a little in our collecting on a much lesser note. There’s so many different levels of this game, that gets played daily, from today to years past.
A lot of variables in that conversation in my mind! 
Tony
March 31, 2009
OfflineI have no idea what the truth is, but Winchester was not a good company to negotiate with. Federal laws were passed to stop some of the things they did to others. Look how many were either bought out or forced out of business. I think Browning was better off going with Belgium and Colt.
November 7, 2015
OfflineI think the global gun business benefitted when Winchester and JMB parted ways. Ego, stubbornness, greed, call it what you want. It worked out well, IMHO. If JMB had stayed with Winchester would we have seen the JMB designed Colt pistols or any of the products JMB invented during his tenure with FN? Would we have seen the Winchester Model 12 and other models designed by T. C. Johnson and others? The author of the above letter was, IIRC, using this opportunity to introduce Johnson’s Model 1903 or at least similar language was used in that announcement. I firmly believe the Browning brothers benefitted from their estrangement from Winchester and other manufacturers benefitted from their talent. I think T.G. Bennett made a mistake but it worked out well for everyone except him.
Mike
January 20, 2023
OfflineBy the time John and Matt Browning went to Bennett and demanded a royalty, the Browning Bros had already been awarded royalties by Colt’s for at least one pistol design, the 1903 hammerless. The brothers had already seen the benefit of doing business in that way and, all things considered, it was not an unreasonable request. I don’t recall the upfront cash they wanted, which could have been a point of negotiation for Bennett, had he been able to get past his resistance to paying a royalty. He couldn’t, which I think cost Winchester a lot of money, not just for the rest of that Decade but for the rest of its existence.
That is often the case with family owned businesses, which Winchester was at the time. Bennett really didn’t have a boss nor did he need or take advice from anyone. Yes, there was a board of directors but it was typically subservient and tame. There was nobody to say, “Tom, do we really want to do this? Is a royalty such a bad idea if we could knock down a big payment in advance? After all, if they win big then we would win bigger.”
It’s the same problem you see when a top salesman starts earning more than his boss and they.start cutting his commission rate. The enlightened boss doesn’t do that. He adds another commission tier with an even higher.rate for more sales than his top guy has already turned in. The enlightened boss wants to make his salesmen rich.
Bennett wanted to protect the family’s interests and likely thought the Browning’s were ungrateful and taking undue advantage. There is always an element of jealousy in these mistakes.
- Bill
WACA # 65205; life member, NRA; member, TGCA; member, TSRA; amateur preservationist
"I have seen wicked men and fools, a great many of both, and I believe they both get paid in the end, but the fools first." -- David Balfour, narrator and protagonist of the novel, Kidnapped, by Robert Louis Stevenson.
April 15, 2005
Offline[email protected] said
Would you rather have the 1911 or the A-5?
Both… and I do! 
WACA Historian & Board of Director Member #6571L

November 7, 2015
Offline[email protected] said
Would you rather have the 1911 or the A-5?
Thanks to the whizzing match I can have either! Personally I have 1911’s since I’ve never warmed up to the Auto-5. Maybe someday.
Mike
3 Guest(s)
Log In
