Winchester 1892 in 44-40|General Discussions & Questions|Forum|Winchester Collector

I have two which more-or-less fit your description.  The first has a brown patina finish, but is all original and letters. I think I paid $1200-1400 for it many years ago.  I’d expect it to fetch around $2000 now.  The second is in much better condition, is a first year production, also letters. I paid $4500 for it about 10 years ago.

I suspect this is the range of prices you’ll find, depending upon condition and the degree of ‘originality’ you desire.

If you are willing to accept some aftermarket modifications, you can probably get one for much less.

Paul

You’ll pay a premium for the 44WCF over the “lesser” chamberings so if it’s a shooter you want then you already have the 32-20 and 25-20. I think the 32WCF is a great shooter but if you want something bigger the 38WCF may be a big bore without the big price, maybe spend the money you save on a higher condition specimen or ammo/loading components. 

Mike

slk said
I am wondering at this point what should a decent 1892 24” barrel crescent butt stock in 44-40 demand these days? I have that rifle in 25-20 and 32-20 and would like to have something in 44-40. I am looking for an old one and not reproduction one. I have not looked very actively yet but just wanted to get an idea of what to expect in price. Basically would like a nice shooter that is not beat to death. Not looking for anything close to mint but just an old honest rifle. 
Thanks
Steve
  

Hello Steve,

Most POS condition 1892’s are selling in the $800 to $1000 range right now on Gunbroker.  A decent shooter grade octagon barrel 44 WCF sporting rifle is going to pretty easily go for +$2000 and one with a bit of condition will nudge $3000.  If you are serious about getting one it takes more than casual looking every few months.  Some serious looking is typically required.

Michael

May I suggest you consider an affordable one with a bad bore that you can have sleeved. 

There is an additional method of improving a pitted barrel if the rifling is still present. There is a ceramic liquid that you swab into the barrel and allow to dry. When dry you take it to the range a fire a series of jacketed bullets that hardens and cures the ceramic coating, which allegedly fills the pits and pulls any sharp edges. How well it works I don’t know. 

There are a lot of 1892 rifles in 44 Winchester but not as many in the condition everybody seems to want. As Mike says, it will take a lot of time and effort to find one that satisfies you and is semi-affordable. 

There is another alternative amd that is to save your money, eat hamburger instead of steak – until you’ve got the cash to bargain for a really nice one that will really appreciate over time. Make it the centerpiece. 

If you are like me, you can do that once but not twice….