September 22, 2011
OfflineTXGunNut said
mrcvs said
Henry Mero said
There are lots of anti – humidity products out there like Damp-Rid , Bamboo packs ,etc., but why on earth would Youwant to keep Your guns in the garage.
The safe in the basement could flood, that’s why I’ve explored the garage idea. Flooding from within and not from outside. Even a pinhole leak from PEX tubing left unchecked could be disastrous. They HAVE happened before but I have caught them in time.
Another problem with a gun safe in the basement is in the event of a fire the water used to extinguish the fire will find its way to the basement. In more extreme cases the gun safe will wind up in the basement but most safes will not protect their contents in this category of fire. If I had a house with a basement I’d give serious thought to a climate-controlled garage. Tools and other toys seem to appreciate moderate environments just as our blue steel and walnut treasures do.
Mike
I never thought of this! My reasoning as to the basement location is that fire works its way vertically. Lower locations being better. Being on a concrete base means the safe can’t fall, hence my basement location.
And so, for these reasons, independent of owning an old bank building with a vault (I would do this if I had the means), where is the best location in a house to put a safe? I would think a one story addition like a covered and enclosed back porch addition (1 story, on a concrete slab) might be the best location, except these tend to not be heated or air conditioned. The next best thing might be the garage, again 1 story, concrete slab, but the heating issue is a problem. If you have more structure surrounding a safe (multiple stories), a fire could be hotter and longer. The issue is these fire resistant safes really aren’t that for a very long period of time.
November 7, 2015
OfflineI suspect in a single-story house with a basement the ground floor would be best as the humidity can be difficult to control in a basement. As we know even a “fire-proof” safe is only rated for given temps for a short time. If the fire consumes the floor of the above-described house I suspect the firearms inside would be in serious trouble or very badly damaged. I live in a rural area so fireproofing would be a waste of money and safe space. My collection is well-insured, I don’t worry as much about fire as other hazards. I believe every collector should take a hard look at their homeowners’ insurance and firearms or collectibles insurance. Better now than when you need it.
Mike
January 20, 2023
OfflineThe insurance industry says the most useful thing about a monitored security system is early fire detection and reporting. If heat and smoke particle sensors are wisely placed, the odds of stopping a fire before it can go over a 1 alarm event are greatly improved. This is more true if you live near a well equipped, full-time fire station. Suburban living has its disadvantages but a lack of quick firefighting response is usually not one of them.
Fires started by lightning strikes are impossible to predict and rare, although there was one in our subdivision. Otherwise, the likely trouble spots are near gas powered HVAC fire boxes and clothes dryers.
Unattended Lithium ion batteries being charged have exploded like Napalm canisters and burned houses to the ground. I think a lot of that starts with cheap no-name batteries and hot-shot chargers without overheat detection circuitry.
The Pacific Rim will build to whatever standard a manufacturer will pay for. I have never had a problem with Nikon, Canon, DeWalt, Bosch, and other quality brands.
I thought iGo lawn equipment batteries were overpriced but one lowball aftermarket substitute battery taught me the difference. It swelled up and got too hot to touch on the charger. Had I left it there overnight, it could well have burned the house down. We have seen three major fires in our subdivision that started from charging Li accessory batteries. Granted, those were years ago when Li was just beginning to replace Nickel Cadmium cells. But I make it a point to buy familiar brands I trust.
I prefer to flip the old saying on its head:
“FIRE, LIKE GOVERNMENT, IS A DANGEROUS SERVANT AND A FEARFUL MASTER.”
- Bill
WACA # 65205; life member, NRA; member, TGCA; member, TSRA; amateur preservationist
"I have seen wicked men and fools, a great many of both, and I believe they both get paid in the end, but the fools first." -- David Balfour, narrator and protagonist of the novel, Kidnapped, by Robert Louis Stevenson.
May 2, 2009
OfflineIf you’re worried about fire the basement is the best place for a gun safe. You can control humidity inside a gun safe if it’s got a door seal. Heat rises and if the its on an upper floor it will be in the basement anyway after a good fire in the middle of the embers heated from all sides. I put a gun safe in the corner of the basement bolted to the wall up on some concrete block to get it off the floor so it has 3 cold sides and if I get water in the basement or from the fire department putting out the fire its off the floor. I then blocked it in top and the remaining side so I have only the door exposed. Smoke damage which starts rust right away is almost as bad as heat damage so a seal on the door is a must. Not the seals that expand from heat since by the time they expand the smoke is inside.
Bob
WACA Life Member--- NRA Life Member---- Cody Firearms member since 1991 Researching the Winchester 1873's

Email: [email protected]
September 22, 2011
OfflineZebulon said
The insurance industry says the most useful thing about a monitored security system is early fire detection and reporting. If heat and smoke particle sensors are wisely placed, the odds of stopping a fire before it can go over a 1 alarm event are greatly improved. This is more true if you live near a well equipped, full-time fire station. Suburban living has its disadvantages but a lack of quick firefighting response is usually not one of them.
Fires started by lightning strikes are impossible to predict and rare, although there was one in our subdivision. Otherwise, the likely trouble spots are near gas powered HVAC fire boxes and clothes dryers.
Unattended Lithium ion batteries being charged have exploded like Napalm canisters and burned houses to the ground. I think a lot of that starts with cheap no-name batteries and hot-shot chargers without overheat detection circuitry.
The Pacific Rim will build to whatever standard a manufacturer will pay for. I have never had a problem with Nikon, Canon, DeWalt, Bosch, and other quality brands.
I thought iGo lawn equipment batteries were overpriced but one lowball aftermarket substitute battery taught me the difference. It swelled up and got too hot to touch on the charger. Had I left it there overnight, it could well have burned the house down. We have seen three major fires in our subdivision that started from charging Li accessory batteries. Granted, those were years ago when Li was just beginning to replace Nickel Cadmium cells. But I make it a point to buy familiar brands I trust.
I prefer to flip the old saying on its head:
“FIRE, LIKE GOVERNMENT, IS A DANGEROUS SERVANT AND A FEARFUL MASTER.”
I agree, better than any safe is a good quality alarm company for both burglars and fire. The response where I live is super quick as well. I think since the advent of good alarm companies, burglaries are way down.
Not to say that a house couldn’t burn to the ground quickly, but recent fires in my subdivision have been modest, at best, and quickly contained. Usually a scorched wall with siding damaged, or much less.
I live in a subdivision. There are very few advantages to this, but the alarm system thing in suburbia is a big one. Also, someone cleaning out my house mid day would raise eyebrows. Lack of privacy can work both ways sometimes.
May 2, 2009
OfflineIn Wisconsin in a wooded rural area we had a house burn down and no one reported it. From the road they thought the guy was burning brush and the guns in the safe were scrape iron. A alarm is required. I had Nest smoke and CO2 alarms and now Nest is not selling them so I switched to First Alert tied to the WiFi so they text me if something happens.
Bob
WACA Life Member--- NRA Life Member---- Cody Firearms member since 1991 Researching the Winchester 1873's

Email: [email protected]
1 Guest(s)
Log In
