Log In
January 19, 2026
Offline
Whiskeyrebellionantiques.com
October 29, 2011
Offline
Looked at their site, no 45-90 listed–Bill
September 22, 2011
Offline
Rough. At $4650, priced at two to three times what it’s worth.
February 17, 2022
Offline
mrcvs said
https://whiskeyrebellionantiques.com/products/antique-winchester-model-1886-45-90-wcf-manufactured-1894-special-order-26-half-octagon-half-round-barrel?_pos=1&_psq=winchester+1886&_psid=d567ff7ef&_ss=e
Rough. At $4650, priced at two to three times what it’s worth.
Ian, I concur. The internet has made every one think they have something special. I would be embarrassed to tell what 4600 has gotten me.
September 22, 2011
Offline
oldcrankyyankee said
mrcvs said
https://whiskeyrebellionantiques.com/products/antique-winchester-model-1886-45-90-wcf-manufactured-1894-special-order-26-half-octagon-half-round-barrel?_pos=1&_psq=winchester+1886&_psid=d567ff7ef&_ss=e
Rough. At $4650, priced at two to three times what it’s worth.
Ian, I concur. The internet has made every one think they have something special. I would be embarrassed to tell what 4600 has gotten me.
You’re joking. Don’t tell me you purchased that wonderful carbine Birthday treat firearm for just that—$4600!
August 7, 2021
Offline
Y’all a little OUTTA touch !
November 2, 2009
Offline
It might be a bit high, but remember half round, half octagon with full mag on a standard sporting rifle in not at all a common feature. Everyone likes a .45-90.
February 17, 2022
Offline
mrcvs said
oldcrankyyankee said
mrcvs said
https://whiskeyrebellionantiques.com/products/antique-winchester-model-1886-45-90-wcf-manufactured-1894-special-order-26-half-octagon-half-round-barrel?_pos=1&_psq=winchester+1886&_psid=d567ff7ef&_ss=e
Rough. At $4650, priced at two to three times what it’s worth.
Ian, I concur. The internet has made every one think they have something special. I would be embarrassed to tell what 4600 has gotten me.
You’re joking. Don’t tell me you purchased that wonderful carbine Birthday treat firearm for just that—$4600!
Defiantly can’t say that! But I have bought some very nice 86’s for that including a deluxe 33 from 1902 and a semi deluxe ELW. And for Mr. Ellison’s sake an antique 86 in 45-90 with an extra heavy 30″ barrel and X wood. Yes it letters. Sorry this sight will no longer let me post pics for some reason, but would be happy too other wise.
April 15, 2005
Offline
oldcrankyyankee said
Sorry this sight will no longer let me post pics for some reason, but would be happy too other wise.
Tom,
As a bona fide WACA member, there is no reason why you cannot post pictures. That stated, you must verify that you are attempting to upload .jpg files versus a .heic file. Many of the new (modern) cell phones and digital camera automatically (default) save all pictures as a “.heic” files unless you change the setting on your camera.
Bert
WACA Historian & Board of Director Member #6571L
February 17, 2022
Offline
Bert I will try again. The photos are filed on my computer and I have posted before.
February 17, 2022
Offline
Sorry Bert, it came back with the same message. HTTP Error. Upload URL might be wrong or doesn’t exist..
July 17, 2012
Online
oldcrankyyankee said
Sorry Bert, it came back with the same message. HTTP Error. Upload URL might be wrong or doesn’t exist..
Your image is attached to your post, it is just not showing with your text. It might be a wee bit too large. Here it is smaller and rotated for you.
WACA Life Member #6284 - Specializing in Pre-64 Winchester .22 Rimfire
February 17, 2022
Offline
JWA said
oldcrankyyankee said
Sorry Bert, it came back with the same message. HTTP Error. Upload URL might be wrong or doesn’t exist..
Your image is attached to your post, it is just not showing with your text. It might be a wee bit too large. Here it is smaller and rotated for you.
Jeff i will check on that. I was trying to post 2 other photos. They obviously didn’t go thru. Computers are my kryptonite!
February 17, 2022
Offline
mrcvs said
oldcrankyyankee said
mrcvs said
https://whiskeyrebellionantiques.com/products/antique-winchester-model-1886-45-90-wcf-manufactured-1894-special-order-26-half-octagon-half-round-barrel?_pos=1&_psq=winchester+1886&_psid=d567ff7ef&_ss=e
Rough. At $4650, priced at two to three times what it’s worth.
Ian, I concur. The internet has made every one think they have something special. I would be embarrassed to tell what 4600 has gotten me.
You’re joking. Don’t tell me you purchased that wonderful carbine Birthday treat firearm for just that—$4600!
Ian, I am struggling to show you some pictures of $4500 86’s. But the one picture JWA fixed for me has one, it is the top one. Semi deluxe ELW.
September 22, 2011
Offline
oldcrankyyankee said
mrcvs said
oldcrankyyankee said
mrcvs said
https://whiskeyrebellionantiques.com/products/antique-winchester-model-1886-45-90-wcf-manufactured-1894-special-order-26-half-octagon-half-round-barrel?_pos=1&_psq=winchester+1886&_psid=d567ff7ef&_ss=e
Rough. At $4650, priced at two to three times what it’s worth.
Ian, I concur. The internet has made every one think they have something special. I would be embarrassed to tell what 4600 has gotten me.
You’re joking. Don’t tell me you purchased that wonderful carbine Birthday treat firearm for just that—$4600!
Ian, I am struggling to show you some pictures of $4500 86’s. But the one picture JWA fixed for me has one, it is the top one. Semi deluxe ELW.
Try me at [email protected]
Also, there’s a PM you never responded to regarding an 1886 Carbine with fancy walnut.
January 28, 2016
Offline
With all that said about the price on the 86 rifle, what’s an original 86 carbine in 45-90, 65% condition worth?
September 22, 2011
Offline
mark minnillo said
With all that said about the price on the 86 rifle, what’s an original 86 carbine in 45-90, 65% condition worth?
Photographs would be a big help.
November 7, 2015
Offline
Thank you oldcrankyyankee and JWA! Just got my RDA of 1886 eye candy, very nice!
Mike
February 17, 2022
Offline
mark minnillo said
With all that said about the price on the 86 rifle, what’s an original 86 carbine in 45-90, 65% condition worth?
Pictures would be a must. But typically carbines bring more money. 45-90 makes it a little more. I know what I paid for mine and I had to do a little negotiating to get there. 
1 Guest(s)
