Log In
January 22, 2022
Offline
<a href="
View post on imgur.com
“>
Hi there I’ve got a model 12 I’m eyeing but trying to decide if it’s a fake or not. The guy says it’s a 1922 super field but I can’t find any info going back that far. I’ve asked for better pictures and waiting for a reply but he says it’s got a solid rib with 2 ivory beads.
November 1, 2013
Offline
Two models in the 1925 catalog resemble this gun, Trap Grade & Tournament Grade. No mention of ivory beads, but I’d be surprised if that wasn’t an option. No mention of a “Super Field” model either.
January 22, 2022
Offline
clarence said
Two models in the 1925 catalog resemble this gun, Trap Grade & Tournament Grade. No mention of ivory beads, but I’d be surprised if that wasn’t an option. No mention of a “Super Field” model either.
Thanks for the help! Both of those would have been clearly marked such on the receiver correct?
November 1, 2013
Offline
Remington Ping said
Thanks for the help! Both of those would have been clearly marked such on the receiver correct?
Not on the rcvr., but possibly on the brl.–I don’t really know.
January 27, 1992
Offline
According to the Dave Riffle “Model 12 Book”, the “Super Grade Field Gun” was introduced about 1955. Everyone was wanting vent rib barrels and Winchester had lot of solid rib barrels on hand. The “Super Field” stock and slide handle wood were upgraded and checked to help sales of the lagging solid rib barrels. Your gun may or may not be marked “TRAP” in the area of the serial number. A “Tournament Trap” model was also available during the time your handsome Model 12 was made. RDB
November 1, 2013
Offline
rogertherelic said
According to the Dave Riffle “Model 12 Book”, the “Super Grade Field Gun” was introduced about 1955.
But if his was built in 1922, it can’t be one of those.
January 22, 2022
Offline
So asides from a letter from the Cody museum is there any defining factors that would indicate it left Winchester in that configuration? Would that recoil pad be time correct? It is a Winchester marked pad
May 26, 2017
Offline
I believe that model 12’s are serial number only from Cody- don’t think configuration is available.run the serial number in the ‘what year was your Winchester made’ on this website and see what year it comes back, that should give you a good start and seeing what its all about.
November 1, 2013
Offline
Remington Ping said
Would that recoil pad be time correct? It is a Winchester marked pad
Very possibly, because a customer who ordered two ivory beads might well have ordered the pad.
January 22, 2022
Offline
I know this is a bit of a loaded question but any questimates on what I should be expecting to give for a questionable shotgun originality in its condition?
November 7, 2015
Online
Remington Ping said
I know this is a bit of a loaded question but any questimates on what I should be expecting to give for a questionable shotgun originality in its condition?
Yes, it is difficult to answer without better pics. It has features of a Trap model but I’m unaware of a “Super Field” model in this time period. Looks like a very nice shotgun. I’d be tempted to offer $1,000 for an 80% gun.
Mike
January 27, 1992
Offline
I have a reprint 1923 WINCHESTER Product Catalog. The graphics aren’t good enough to scan and reproduce on the Forum. The “Tournament Grade” Model 12 has very similar stocks and checking style. All the “TRAP” models are pictured with the “English” or straight stocks. The Winchester “Red” recoil pad was introduced in 1922. RDB
January 22, 2022
Offline
rogertherelic said
I have a reprint 1923 WINCHESTER Product Catalog. The graphics aren’t good enough to scan and reproduce on the Forum. The “Tournament Grade” Model 12 has very similar stocks and checking style. All the “TRAP” models are pictured with the “English” or straight stocks. The Winchester “Red” recoil pad was introduced in 1922. RDB
Oh thanks! The tournament shows with a pistol grip stock? Did those not get black Diamonds inlay?
November 1, 2013
Offline
Remington Ping said
Oh thanks! The tournament shows with a pistol grip stock? Did those not get black Diamonds inlay?
In my ’25 catalog, both Trap & Tournament are shown with straight-grip stocks. Reading descriptions, only diff I see is that the Trap stocks were all hand-made & would be built to customer’s specs at no extra charge; maybe this is what the black diamond signified. Suspect it could also be had with a PG, if that’s what was ordered, but that would be unusual for any trap gun.
January 27, 1992
Offline
Tournament grade had less and simpler checking patterns on the stock and slide handle. They were only marked “TOURNAMENT” under the butt plate or pad. I personally find the subdued pistol grip very elegant and sleek looking. RDB
January 22, 2022
Offline
So we’re leaning towards this either being a custom order then or something someone has pieced together over the years? Trying to setup a meeting with the fella but afraid of over spending on it
August 27, 2014
Offline
What’s the S/N?
“If you can’t convince them, confuse them”
President Harry S. Truman
November 1, 2013
Offline
Remington Ping said
So we’re leaning towards this either being a custom order then or something someone has pieced together over the years? Trying to setup a meeting with the fella but afraid of over spending on it
No reason to suspect it’s been “pieced together,” but I wouldn’t waste my time with a seller who hasn’t provided at least a ball-park price, & if he has, what is it? If doesn’t really know what he wants for it, tell him to call you back when he does. Options like the pad & beads were not uncommon, esp. on skeet & trap guns.
January 22, 2022
Offline
He wants $600 for it. I talked to my lgs and their value book is older but they thought if it wasn’t one of the special packages it was a $500 gun. Serial number the fella gave me was 2922XX
November 1, 2013
Offline
Remington Ping said
He wants $600 for it. I talked to my lgs and their value book is older but they thought if it wasn’t one of the special packages it was a $500 gun. Serial number the fella gave me was 2922XX
Buy it, then resell it for $1000 to TxGun Nut! But the seller is not unreasonable, as many are–$600 seems a fair price to me, but it wouldn’t hurt to offer (politely) $500 first. If the recoil pad is cracked or crumbling, which is often the problem with pads this old, I’d use that to bargain. Repro pads are available, but having them fitted is a hassle.
