1887|Winchester Shotguns|Forum|Winchester Collector

Jim, my guess would be a weak or broken spring.  But, I have never worked on mine. 

https://www.google.com/search?q=winchester+1887+parts+diagram&tbm=isch&source=iu&ictx=1&fir=njtpPW9EKTywfM%252Ck4v89smQHNO7PM%252C_%253BbKmJqgei3JY_NM%252Cg5AaR3OGviJVcM%252C_%253BBdyAjEE4b1SqPM%252CvUwUcwaRpXAL3M%252C_%253BDfKI0dY0c8Qh0M%252CTyw6tAFgemcPnM%252C_%253BQX9kO16Df3kFvM%252C2p0m7ZFeGvt21M%252C_%253BCZ2kpgTgJ1uPgM%252CwUdFWZWe9qXmJM%252C_%253B7DgZEntIeO73jM%252CmCGfsMeU_bA8tM%252C_%253B5qtCIS-KyyNBIM%252C-3p6DdyyQ0ofjM%252C_%253B8vWfGcg_gqEmcM%252Cvp2UaaC49V9-EM%252C_%253BUUCwjOfmZSViDM%252C-3p6DdyyQ0ofjM%252C_%253BZEvDvaF1bBVrlM%252C1nfN49kU9zM0sM%252C_%253BMTTT6AfrE-n33M%252CRdM4-agmAmfWaM%252C_%253BnyxOP2WvaVTc6M%252C7NczmGALjQozTM%252C_%253BIUS_k9bbzIeFiM%252CoGmjVrl0ALa7_M%252C_%253BB6bhsSBTpgdhQM%252CGcpLNm3ag8y96M%252C_%253BUXEPU8x-lEkHFM%252CppfxUk3a6cby2M%252C_&vet=1&usg=AI4_-kRLcBU53fWSUPvNc35RzDHrVY6iZg&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjztJT2ko7zAhWiMX0KHScmBykQ9QF6BAgdEAE&biw=1470&bih=1014&dpr=1.25#imgrc=svkBbXdc7KApaM

If you look at the picture on the right it appears there is a flat spring that may be for the action/lever?