Log In
November 7, 2019
Offline
Made in 1890, this originally case hardened 1873 is chambered in 38WCF. The pictures admittedly aren’t that great, but I was hoping I could get some help determining the value of this rifle. Thank you
January 19, 2017
Offline
Looks like my kind of rifle. Loading port spring cover looks new/replacement. The screw head on the lower tang looks strange. The finish looks like it went bad and then someone tried to clean it up. But I don’t go for the fancy stuff. If closer examination didn’t show anything worse, I’d pay $1,000.00 but I bet others would go $1,500.00. I am NO expert. Here to learn what others say.
November 7, 2019
Offline
Thank you, Huck I appreciate your insight and opinion. The fella selling it states it’s original but it seems everyone says that…he’s asking $1900
May 2, 2009
Offline
Don,
You said it was case colored, Do you have a letter on it or did you look under the side plates? If it was its long gone. The value of the case color is only if there is some left on it. Once the case is gone the value is gone. That gun is worth $1200 in todays market.
Bob
WACA Life Member--- NRA Life Member---- Cody Firearms member since 1991 Researching the Winchester 1873's
Email: [email protected]
November 7, 2019
Offline
No I don’t. That’s per the current owner and What he said his gunsmith told him. Thank you for the valuation. I have not laid hands or eyes on the rifle.
November 2, 2009
Offline
Unfortunately, most “gunsmiths” don’t know anything about antique firearms. Like 1873 man said, you should be able to tell if it had been case colored by pulling the side plates. Otherwise a Cody letter is your best bet. In my opinion $1900 is way over the top. This is only a $1200 to $1500 Winchester, at best. The condition can only be graded as good. If bore is fair and action tight, it might make a good shooter.
November 7, 2019
Offline
Really appreciate all the info gents!
November 19, 2006
Online
I’m in the $1200 valuation range as well and agree with the comments above. In my mind, the key comment above is from 1873 man: “… in today’s market.” I find that many sellers continue to price their items in line with yesterday’s market. That’s why lots of sellers are sitting on what they have.
June 4, 2017
Offline
steve004 said
I’m in the $1200 valuation range as well and agree with the comments above. In my mind, the key comment above is from 1873 man: “… in today’s market.” I find that many sellers continue to price their items in line with yesterday’s market. That’s why lots of sellers are sitting on what they have.
Steve, Well said. T/R
November 7, 2015
Offline
My observation of “today’s market” is that it’s nearly flooded with guns of similar condition to this one. Not only will it bring less than many collectors/dealers think it should but it will be hard to sell. As noted above it could be a solid shooter if the bore and action are sound. I think if you’ll be patient and keep looking you’ll find a better gun for $1900.
Mike
