November 7, 2015
Offline1badf350 said
Thank you everyone. I’m probably going to sell it. Any idea on fair price?
Is the butt stamped “Winchester”?
Mike
December 31, 2012
OfflineSteven Gabrielli said
That thumb trigger model ain’t easy to find either Boss.
Usually found as a pretty bad beater. Even then, expensive. I have only seen one that was a good 98%. Most nice ones are restorations being passed off as 98%ers. Mine, pictured, is a beater, and has a bore like a stove pipe. But, the redeeming factor of this rifle is that it has a nice, un cracked, stock. It’s shootable. Big Larry
December 31, 2012
OfflineTXGunNut said
1badf350 said
Thank you everyone. I’m probably going to sell it. Any idea on fair price?
Is the butt stamped “Winchester”?
Mike
Mike, according to JWA, the books are wrong about the Winchester marked stocks. The plain ones are the lesser of the two. Big Larry
December 31, 2012
Offline1badf350 said
Butt is not stamped Winchester but I don’t think it’s supposed to be.
Some have the name WINCHESTER embossed in the butt. Mine is like yours, an early model, with the plain butt. I cannot give you a value, but these generally go for high dollars. They made bunches of them, but their survival rate is extremely low. They were real cheap and therefore not much care was taken with them. Add to that, the ammo of the day ate the bores up. Put it up for sale for offers in our classifieds. Someone here may want one. Big Larry
April 15, 2005
Offline1badf350 said
Sorry to bump an old thread but can you tell me what is meant by “thumb trigger” ?
Watch this video… Bing Videos
Thumb Trigger at cock…
![]()
Bert
WACA Historian & Board of Director Member #6571L

February 13, 2012
OfflineBert H. said
1badf350 said
Sorry to bump an old thread but can you tell me what is meant by “thumb trigger” ?
Watch this video… Bing Videos
Thumb Trigger at cock…
Bert
Thanks Bert it doesn’t appear that mine has that. I got confused by the posts talking about it and thought it was in reference to my rifle
December 9, 2002
Offline1badf350 said
Bert H. said
1badf350 said
Sorry to bump an old thread but can you tell me what is meant by “thumb trigger” ?
Watch this video… Bing Videos
Thumb Trigger at cock…
Bert
Thanks Bert it doesn’t appear that mine has that. I got confused by the posts talking about it and thought it was in reference to my rifle
Bert’s video that he put in place for us, explains the Thumb trigger, also referred to as the Model-99, very well, for those that wasn’t aware of how they operate. If you thought you’re Model 1900, that was mfg. 1900-1902, was anything like the 1900, where the early examples had the ‘Winchester Embossed Butt”, as many here have suggester, as the later examples were void of this. There’s no similarity from the “Thumb Trigger”,(mfg. 1904-1923), model to any other .22 caliber Winchester rifle. All of the other .22 caliber rifles has a Trigger guard under the stock, to protect the more common trigger, found underneath on most firearms.
Tony. R said
Steven Gabrielli said
That thumb trigger model ain’t easy to find either Boss.
Because Winchester dumped most of them out hear downunder.
Steven,
I agree with you as they are hard to find, and when one is found in nice original condition, they usually command a premium!
Tony R.
I didn’t realize they we’re dumped down under! Thanks for that! 
Anthony
March 15, 2020
Offlineregarding my model 58: The barrel is stamped “MADE IN U. S. A. WINCHESTER REPEATING ARMS CO. —MODEL 58 — 22 SHORT—- WINCHESTER—
NEW HAVEN CONN. PATENTED AUGUST 29, 1898, — LONG AND LONG RIFLE— TRADE MARK—
It also has PW in oval at breech. The rifling is thin but no pitting (per my old eyes)
Is that standard stamping on old guns? Don
July 17, 2012
OfflineThat is the standard barrel roll mark on the Model 58. It should also have a WP stamp on the top of the bolt.
Best Regards,
WACA Life Member #6284 - Specializing in Pre-64 Winchester .22 Rimfire
June 1, 2023
OfflineI was taught how to shoot (more than sixty years ago) with a Winchester Model 58 that my dad had purchased, because it reminded him of the Winchester 1902 rifle with which his grandfather taught him to shoot, back in the 1930’s. Sadly, I let that Model 58 go when other, more pressing financial matters came up. It was a rare model in exceptionally fine condition. I still remember that little rifle fondly.
BRP
December 9, 2002
OfflineAs a follow up, I finally got around to getting this one out, as I was moving some things around. Just for the conversation sake of a hard to find M-1900, and the embossed butt with “Winchester”, on it. I wanted to show the “Embossed Winchester Logo”, on the Butt!














It’s pretty obvious that the gum wood stock, looks to have been refreshed. The collection that it came out of several years ago didn’t have one refinished .22 caliber rifle in it. This one had been looked at by many, years ago, as I still wonder. Even the Embossed, “Winchester”, Logo that looks to have some darker chocolate color to it, has had me perplexed for a long while. It’s still a nice example, and the only one that I kept, out of the few that I acquired, years ago, in collections obtained.The others were all extremely used and worn out.
The Bore is shiny and clean on it, as it’s hard to really tell the twist rate on it. The blue on the barrel is starting to get a deep patina Hugh to it, as it looks nice. 
Now, in further examining, and in removing the barrel in the natural light. It’s very evident, that this rifle has been refinished, years ago, as the vise like dimple marks, are very evident, and obvious in the hidden areas, of the stock.With the barrel removed, the in-letting on the Gum Wood stock has it’s normal appearance, but there’s remnants of some shiny gloss finish spilled along the edges of the inside part of the stock. Even some pitting is exposed near the front of the barrel, and covered in old style bluing. IMO!
So rather to “Caution on the side of error”, I would much rather say that this gun looks refinished to me! As it absolutely has been!!! IMHO!




JWA said
Yes, that appears to be a 1st variation (early) Winchester Model 1900, the first variation was not marked with a model number for some reason, the second variations (2a and 2b) were marked “MODEL 1900 / 22 SHORT & LONG” after the address and patent roll marking.
Best Regards,
JWA said
The first variation Model 1900’s were marked like this and only had 22 Short Long marked at the breech:
MANUFACTURED BY THE WINCHESTER REPEATING ARMS CO.
NEW HAVEN CONN. U.S.A. PAT. AUG. 29, 1899.
Best Regards,
According to JWA, it looks like a second variation, (2a or a 2b). I did nor know or realize this. Thanks, Jeff! 
Tony
1 Guest(s)
Log In

