Winchester Collector - Forum: Winchester Swap Meet

348win on WTB Model 12 Pump Shotgun in 16ga 26" RIB 2 3/4" SHOOTER GRADE

Sun, 13 Sep 2026 15:50:39 +0000

I'm searching for a Model 12 in 16 gauge.

- Its got to have a 26" barrel (I don't think 25" is an option?)

- 2 3/4" chambering for modern ammo

- Ribbed Barrel; was told Solid Rib is more durable for hunting

- I suspect I'm looking for a 1940's - 1960's model

Jeremy P on FOR SALE: 1969 Winchester Model 94 Theodore Roosevelt Consecutive Pair — TR43293 & TR43294

Sun, 13 Sep 2026 14:20:33 +0000

You could always throw them to one of the higher end auctions and see what they bring if you're feeling risky! With your description, they might do well!

krazykev on FOR SALE: 1969 Winchester Model 94 Theodore Roosevelt Consecutive Pair — TR43293 & TR43294

Sun, 13 Sep 2026 13:16:47 +0000

Thanks everyone for taking the time to comment. I appreciate the input, especially from those of you who have been collecting Winchester commemoratives for a long time.

I understand the points being made about the market for Theodore Roosevelt consecutive sets, and the information on actual collector demand has been helpful.

One reason I initially valued this pair higher is the completeness of the set. TR43293 and TR43294 have remained together as a consecutive rifle/carbine pair and include the individual boxes and paperwork, along with the original Winchester two-gun shipping carton marked with both serial numbers. I haven't seen many complete consecutive sets offered with that original serial-numbered outer carton still present.

I'm not trying to argue with the experience represented here, and I appreciate the education. I'm going to reconsider the asking price based on the feedback I've received.

I'd still like to see the complete set stay together and go to someone who appreciates what it is. If anyone here has a serious interest in the pair, feel free to reach out to me privately with a reasonable offer.

Thanks again for all the information and help.

Hatchetjack on Vintage western super match 22 ammo

Sat, 12 Sep 2026 21:13:42 +0000

No sir , the older version

Zebulon on WTS Cody Firearma Museum by HH

Fri, 11 Sep 2026 19:10:32 +0000

Sold one. PM me a mailing address and the all up number. The check will be "in the mail."

TW56 on Vintage western super match 22 ammo

Fri, 11 Sep 2026 15:05:20 +0000

Is this the Vintage Western Super Match you are looking for?

View post on imgur.com

Ross

KYMason on WTB-Original 1940s Winchester Model 12 Trap Wood Set (12-Gauge)

Fri, 11 Sep 2026 12:30:06 +0000

I am looking to source a 100% authentic, vintage early-1940s (gun is an 1941) and a late-1940s (gun is a 1949) factory Winchester Model 12 Trap wood set for a restoration project.
I am restoring an immaculate 1941 and a 1949 factory-milled duckbill Trap model. I require a period-correct, factory-checkered Trap buttstock and a matching checkered extension trap forend. Must be original Pre-64 vintage wood profiles (no post-1964 Y-Series, Sile reproductions, or modern field wood). Might consider a real nice custom set. Honest finish wear is perfectly fine, but the wood must be structurally sound without heavy sanding or major cracks.
Please PM me with clear photos and your asking price if you have a set or individual pieces available. Thank you!

Honest Jon on Winchester Replica Swap Meet Posting

Thu, 10 Sep 2026 23:40:55 +0000

Good advice comes in spades from WACA!

Thank you,

Jon

Zebulon on Winchester Replica Swap Meet Posting

Thu, 10 Sep 2026 21:12:43 +0000

Jon, as an occasional seller on Gunbroker over a couple of Decades, I think you will get the widest pool of potential buyers and the fees are relatively low there but there are some tricks to getting a good price.

1. Knowing what your gun is worth at retail and wholesale. The best way I know of to do this is, first of all, become a member of Gunbroker if you are not already. This can take some time because they are constantly beset with scammers and fraudulent sellers. Their security protocols are tougher than once.

2. Being a member allows you to search closed auctions to see what guns like yours have hammered for. It is best to sort search results by "highest number of bids first" rather than dollars because a lot of high dollar starting price auctions close with 0 bids.

3. Good and extensive photography is very important. Doesn't have to be professional but a couple snaps with a Brownie Hawkeye won't get it done.

4. Honest descriptions- not just a line or two.

5. The best way to ensure a sale is a long auction term - two weeks - and a penny start. Yes, there is a risk. The current Money Market rate is your competitor. Dealers shop for inventory on Gunbroker and any nominal start will draw lowball bids. Dealers want to pay about 60% of retail. If your gun is in nice condition AND there is a market for the model, you can usually get at least that.

6. Another alternative is to set a fixed price and run it for 90 days. It will appear discouraging because the dealers have no interest - you are retailing it. If your gun is hard to find, that is a good way to sell but you must be patient.

If you have any questions, you can PM me with your email address and we can correspond that way.

Logan on Winchester Replica Swap Meet Posting

Thu, 10 Sep 2026 20:59:18 +0000

Jon,

The American Single Shot Rifle Association (ASSRA) forum is also a great place to buy and sell single shots. You could list your non-winchester stuff there if you don’t want to go with one of the big guys. Great folks over there, a lot of them are here too.

Logan

JWA on Winchester Replica Swap Meet Posting

Thu, 10 Sep 2026 19:29:23 +0000

A few of us do have interest but we are in the minority which is not usually conducive to the best marketing plan 😉

If you don't want to personally deal with Gunbroker or Guns International there are some good auction companies that will take care of getting you a good price for it. Lock, Stock and Barrel located in Cody, Wyoming is an example of one of many. In addition to their standard firearm auctions, LSB lists some guns directly on Gunbroker if requested.

Best Regards,

Honest Jon on Winchester Replica Swap Meet Posting

Thu, 10 Sep 2026 19:10:43 +0000

Please, don't make this an issue based on my question! I can find other outlets I'm sure but thought members of this forum would have the most collective interest.

Yours,

Jon

JWA on Winchester Replica Swap Meet Posting

Thu, 10 Sep 2026 19:05:42 +0000

Jon,

Wow, that one is really on the fence. While it is a cool Winchester replica, that particular example was not made by Winchester nor was it made under license since the patents have long expired for the 1885 so it does not exactly meet our rules as currently written. To accommodate the Sharps 1885 would be the same as allowing Uberti replicas, Rossi and Taurus replicas (of the Model 62), etc.

In a nutshell, the original intent was to limit the Swap Meet firearms to only those that are actually marked "Winchester" which is why the rules state "under license" since that is required by Olin to use the name "Winchester" on any firearm.

I will bring up the topic with the WACA board and see if there is any interest in updating the rules as written.

Thanks for your understanding.

Best Regards,

Honest Jon on Winchester Replica Swap Meet Posting

Thu, 10 Sep 2026 17:53:06 +0000

Thank you for your replies. That’s how I read the guidelines as well. The rifle happens to be an 1885 High Wall Sporting Rifle manufactured by C. Sharps.

Jon

deerhunter on Book for sale: The Winchester Single Shot; A History & Analysis by John Campbell, 1995 (270 pages)

Thu, 10 Sep 2026 17:27:34 +0000

Honest Jon said
I'll take it Don...PM to follow.
Jon

Sale pending. Thanks Jon. Sending PM.