Just a thought. Don

I would agree with BRP-your honesty and integrity is to be commended.

Kevin 

I seem to recall you purchased these in good faith, I hope you can be reimbursed. Maybe complimentary tables at the Cody Show. I suspect they will be a popular item when offered, just as tables at the Cody Show seem to be.

Mike

I think you have done the right thing, and I applaud your honesty and decency in doing so. 

BRP

Thanks to everyone for your interest and I hope everyone feels WACA getting these is the right outcome!

Winchester holsters for Colt Single Action Army

steve004 said  

Buck94 -
I didn't know anything about these, but that's a fine detailed analysis.
  

I agree, that is more detailed information than would have come from a professional appraiser.  Nice job Buck94!

Best Regards,

Buck94 said
These appear to be World War II military cartons of Winchester 9mm Parabellum, packed 64 rounds for submachine guns (Sten and similar Allied contracts). The Imperial War Museum has the same style dated 1941. What you have looks like a mixed lot, and the printed boxes are the ones with value.
Of the the Five boxes
•  Two full-legend boxes (top left and bottom left): “WINCHESTER / 9m/m PARABELLUM / 64-CARTRIDGES / FOR USE IN Sub-Machine Guns,” with the W.R.A. Co. mark and “Division of Western Cartridge Co., New Haven.” These are the collector pieces.
•  Three plain cartons marked only “9m/m PARABELLUM CARTRIDGES 64,” two with later yellow “9mm Luger” stickers and one with red ink (“W.S.” and a date-style note). Those are the common inner or later military cartons.
Condition on all of them is fair and used: soiling, edge wear, and tape residue. None look sealed or near-new.
Looking at recent comps online I found one:
•  A full vintage Winchester “for use in sub-machine guns” box is about $70 retail at Checkpoint Charlie’s (50-round version). A dated 1942–43 full box is listed at $200, which is an asking price, not a sale.
Just my opinion, the realistic U.S. range, as they sit:
•  Full printed box, complete and original: about $40–80. Early headstamps (1941–43 WRA) and clean cartridges push the top of that; a shop might ask $100–150.
•  Empty printed box: about $15–35, as a display piece next to a Sten or Luger. Or add a zero if from one of our crazy eBay sellers 😀
•  Plain 64-round carton: about $20–40 if full (mostly the ammo), $5–15 empty.
As a lot, if all five are full and original, figure roughly $150–300 at a gun show or local sale, maybe $350 if the two labeled boxes check out with matching WRA rounds. If they are empty, the two printed boxes carry almost all the value, about $40–70 together.
The photo only shows the tops, so contents, headstamps, and whether the rounds are original to the boxes are the difference between the low and high end. A side shot of the end flaps and a cartridge headstamp would tighten this. Old military 9mm is a collector item first; don’t assume it is safe to shoot without checking the primers and cases.
The devil is in the details and as always, the value of collectibles can vary wildly by the market you choose and the pool of buyers. Bottom line in my opinion is “Do Not” let your daughter shoot them! They are collectible, a nice conversation piece and should increase in value. 
  

Buck94 -

I didn't know anything about these, but that's a fine detailed analysis.

Of the the Five boxes

•  Two full-legend boxes (top left and bottom left): “WINCHESTER / 9m/m PARABELLUM / 64-CARTRIDGES / FOR USE IN Sub-Machine Guns,” with the W.R.A. Co. mark and “Division of Western Cartridge Co., New Haven.” These are the collector pieces.

•  Three plain cartons marked only “9m/m PARABELLUM CARTRIDGES 64,” two with later yellow “9mm Luger” stickers and one with red ink (“W.S.” and a date-style note). Those are the common inner or later military cartons.

Condition on all of them is fair and used: soiling, edge wear, and tape residue. None look sealed or near-new.

Looking at recent comps online I found one:

•  A full vintage Winchester “for use in sub-machine guns” box is about $70 retail at Checkpoint Charlie’s (50-round version). A dated 1942–43 full box is listed at $200, which is an asking price, not a sale.

Just my opinion, the realistic U.S. range, as they sit:

•  Full printed box, complete and original: about $40–80. Early headstamps (1941–43 WRA) and clean cartridges push the top of that; a shop might ask $100–150.

•  Empty printed box: about $15–35, as a display piece next to a Sten or Luger. Or add a zero if from one of our crazy eBay sellers 😀

•  Plain 64-round carton: about $20–40 if full (mostly the ammo), $5–15 empty.

As a lot, if all five are full and original, figure roughly $150–300 at a gun show or local sale, maybe $350 if the two labeled boxes check out with matching WRA rounds. If they are empty, the two printed boxes carry almost all the value, about $40–70 together.

The photo only shows the tops, so contents, headstamps, and whether the rounds are original to the boxes are the difference between the low and high end. A side shot of the end flaps and a cartridge headstamp would tighten this. Old military 9mm is a collector item first; don’t assume it is safe to shoot without checking the primers and cases.

The devil is in the details and as always, the value of collectibles can vary wildly by the market you choose and the pool of buyers. Bottom line in my opinion is “Do Not” let your daughter shoot them! They are collectible, a nice conversation piece and should increase in value. 

ssdave said
Didn't mean to start a thread and walk away, just got busy with other things.
Haven't done anything with the 9mm, I'll have to find time this winter to deal with them.  Never occurred to me that they might be too hot for modern handguns, I'll pass on giving them to my daughter to shoot.  Same lot of stuff these came from, got a few thousand modern 9mm, so she can shooot those up for a while.
  

I’ll buy a box when you’re ready to sell them. 

Haven't done anything with the 9mm, I'll have to find time this winter to deal with them.  Never occurred to me that they might be too hot for modern handguns, I'll pass on giving them to my daughter to shoot.  Same lot of stuff these came from, got a few thousand modern 9mm, so she can shooot those up for a while.